Friday, August 29, 2008 Last Update: 2:27 p.m.
Fair: Currently 73° F
Dow: 11543.96 -171.22

Is the Future for the Illinois GOP as Bleak as Pundits Say? Yep!

For Illinois Republicans this is the midst of a great depression. The news that suburban voters, even in the GOP heartland of DuPage County, pulled more Democrat than Republican ballots in the primary is an ominous foreshadowing of a very bleak November.

The likely presence of Sen. Barack Obama (D-IL) on the national ticket makes a bad situation much worse. Obama is a favorite son who has energized the Democratic party nationally and has whipped it up to frenzy here in Illinois. The odds are very strong that Obama will be on the national ticket. I picked him to win last summer, believing there were just too many Democrats who don’t like Sen. Hillary Clinton (D-NY). Now, though, even if Clinton’s organizational strength prevails she almost has to work hard to persuade him to take the vice-presidential slot, whatever her personal preferences. With the racially-charged attacks the Clintons made against Obama leading up to the South Carolina primary anything less is liable to leave many black voters sitting out the November election. The Democratic coalition is so structured that anything less than a monolithic black vote for Democrats leaves them in a position where they cannot win.

Meanwhile, even as Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) takes a commanding lead in the Republican race, rank-and-file conservatives remain unenthused about him. With his past spats with the right wing the best he can do is probably to accomplish a cease-fire in hostilities with the base. McCain is usually at his best when dealing with setbacks – and at his acerbic worst when dealing with prosperity. It leaves me doubtful that he will successfully manage a productive truce with social conservatives.

What that means is that, in Illinois, Democratic voters will be invigorated while Republican voters will likely suffer from more than a little torpor come November. That could have a profound effect beyond the presidential election. It will be very difficult for the GOP caucuses in either the Illinois house or senate to make any gains – and they probably should brace themselves for more losses. It becomes extremely unlikely that Republicans can take back the 8th Congressional Dist. (Melissa Bean’s seat) this year. Three seats currently held by Republicans become vulnerable. Most likely to switch hands is the 11th, Jerry Weller’s old seat. Democrats are united behind popular State Sen. Debbie Halvorsen. Republicans nominated the worthy, but little-known Tim Baldermann, mayor of New Lenox. Incumbent Republican Mark Kirk of the 10th faces a rematch with his 2006 opponent, Dan Seals. Kirk sits in one of the oddest districts in the state, if not the country – a genuinely liberal Republican district. Seals came far too close for comfort in ’06. An Obama-led Democratic tide in Illinois in ’08 could sweep Kirk away. Over in the 14th, former Speaker Denny Hastert’s district, Jim Oberweis just won a bitter dogfight of a primary with State Sen. Chris Lauzen. Though the 14th remains a Republican-leaning district, if the deep wounds inflicted by the primary are not healed and there is a surge of Democratic voters, the district could be vulnerable. I suspect matters will be helped if Oberweis is the incumbent congressman, which he should be. The special election to fill Hastert’s seat next month is a stand-alone election. Democrats will not be helped by a surge of voters coming out to mark for Obama then.

Even 6th Dist. Rep. Peter Roskam could have a real battle on his hands. Though Roskam has been tone-perfect in his first term, the district is competitive enough that a Democratic surge could make him sweat. The only open seat that looks to remain safely in Republican hands is the 18th, where State Rep. Aaron Schock looks to smoothly replace the retiring Ray LaHood.

In the U.S. Senate incumbent Democrat Dick Durbin would likely cruise easily to victory past the underfunded, overmatched Dr. Steve Sauerberg even without a strong prevailing Democratic wind.

For each of the past three election cycles Illinois Republicans have consoled themselves after drubbings that it couldn’t get any worse – and then the next cycle was worse. This is clearly likely to be the worst of all. So is there any light signaling the end of this very long, dark tunnel? Actually there is, but only if Republicans play a different game than they have the last six years.

First, the opening. Rod Blagojevich has been, possibly, the worst governor in Illinois history. Even as the national economy expanded through most of his tenure job creation in Illinois plummeted towards the bottom of the states. If this were Arkansas or Mississippi that might not mean much, but Illinois has traditionally been the strong economic engine of the midwest. You really have to work at it to make it sputter. Illinois finances are in disastrous shape. Our deficit has expanded geometrically under Blagojevich, who has tried to pay short-term obligations by selling capital assets – a precursor to complete collapse in any financial scenario.

Even so, Blagojevich is not as heavy an albatross to Democrats as George Ryan was to Republicans. Ryan clearly was the embodiment of the Republican establishment so all Republicans paid, in some measure, for his failures. But the state’s most prominent Democrats vie with Republicans in the vehemence of their detestation for Blagojevich. So voters are more likely to regard Blagojevich as an aberration rather than a symptom of Democratic malfeasance. Barring a major federal indictment, though, the governor is not likely to go quietly into retirement. That means there is a profound likelihood that he and Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan will engage in a blood-feud during the 2010 Democratic Primary. The result could leave the divided Democrats very vulnerable.

That won’t mean a thing if Republicans turn primary season into the usual circular firing squad. The fact is that Republicans don’t have a stopper in statewide politics. Democrats do in both Barack Obama and the gifted political leadership of Mike Madigan. In order to have a chance to take advantage of Democratic divisions, Republicans must, for once, act with genuine unity. That means crafting a slate of statewide candidates who are both geographically and ideologically balanced – and turning a cold shoulder to self-promoting gadflies. It would mean that the most extreme partisans of both the moderate and conservative wings of the party would need to either shut up or be ignored by those who would like to put an end to the extreme liberal governance of Illinois. It would mean getting all elements of the party to work together to select candidates who best match up with their districts in open or competitive legislative and congressional seats.

When the New England Patriots first emerged as a premier team they did it without marquee stars. It was teamwork and careful execution of their assigned positions that made them a superb team. That is the motif Illinois Republicans must follow if we are to emerge from the wilderness.

I don’t see any way we Illinois Republicans can do much more than beg, “Buddy, can you spare a vote,” this cycle. But if we are shrewd, disciplined, large-spirited and start working now we can turn 2010 into a great rags to riches story.

_________________________________________

Charlie Johnston is an expert in grassroots organization and is a regular columnist for The Chicago Daily Observer.

Commentary:

1

Garp says:

As a Democrat, I am not sad for the demise of the Illinois Repubs, however, I will give you some hope. Things do change. It wasn't that long ago that the Repubs took over both state houses and we were scrambling to get democrats elected so the you guys didn't take over Chicago Airports. So take heart and don't give up, we love a good fight.

February 12, 2008 at 10:47 a.m.
2

Art says:

It's sweet victory anytime politicians that abuse the public trust get dumped.

The R's took those abuses to a new level; they fooled the religious wrong and both patriots & flag-waving idiots far and wide.

I hope Obama gets the monination as I'm not a big fan of Hillary or Bill; she is still a better option than another warmonger & fearmonger or missing village idiot from Texas.

I'm tired of D's & R's and the electoral process. Can't we just elect the best candidate? (Except for governor, where we can't seem to GET a decent candidate.)

February 12, 2008 at 2:16 p.m.
3

Heath says:

Yeah, one-party rule in Illinois or anywhere for that matter is always a great thing and never bring corruption or trouble...(rolling my eyes)

February 13, 2008 at 12:29 a.m.
4

stan says:

As you have noticed we are loosing to the Democrats just look at the numbers of the turnout and the age gap in all voting! The Media candidate McCain can not win against Obama no how no way! People do want change and you will not see it in McCain.

I'm like most Republicans totally dissatisfied with what has happened to the GOP! Since when do we adopt a 100 year war, Pre-emptive War, torture and support for Dictators around the world all the while our boarders are open during this so called war? We have lost all conservatism and have become liberal as a Party! We have spent everything we had we now borrow to no end it will come time soon enough to pay up but the status quo will not pay it your children and grandchildren will how nice! The status quo will not fight in foreign wars your children and grandchildren will!

It is time to decide what to do about it. Vote Democratic socialism or vote current Neo-Con liberalism, endless wars and loss of individual rights and privacy. Unfortunately I think neither at the moment is a good choice or the few can team up stand up to make a difference that meaning taking over the status quo from within changing rules changing bylaws and becoming more proactive then the sheep of the status quo. In the end America is apathetic and things will change once the real economy shows it's real weakness after this election and the GOP gets a well deserved beating for not being genuine Republicans.

Yes the GOP has lost it's way be prepared to be slaughtered by the democrat Obama take the medicine and move on and enjoy your social security and your Sunday church service while the young die in foreign lands protecting your life style. The young will rise up and re-establish the GOP from scratch with no Social Security and no Draft and the restoration of a real fiscal responsibility. The old GOP will be no more like it is today after this loss mark my words.

February 13, 2008 at 7:35 a.m.
5

Tolson says:

Simply put, part of why Illinois Republicans are in the state they are is of people like the author of this column.

While this is strictly opinion based on the author above, he speaks from no real experience. He has made a living of serving as a "political consultant" to a number of candidates, the common denominator amongst them being - they all lost.

It is a litany of familiar names Salvi (lost three times), Churchill (lost twice), McSweeney, Zinga (lost twice). These self-styled "political consultants" which the author counts himself amongst, take a paycheck with no results.

The Illinois GOP has three major problems:

1.) Lack of leadership. The state party is not the machine it used to be. Whatever money they raise goes to pay staff salaries and for expensive office rent on Randolph Street in Chicago, arguably the least Republican area in the state. The current chairman shows no leadership in cultivating future candidates, assisting current ones, or building a field organization. In addition, there's just enough money to pay an executive director $100,000 a year and keep the lights on.

2.) Lack of likable, electable candidates. No more Judy Baar Topinkas or David McSweeneys, thank you very much.

3.) "Political Consultants" that take a big paycheck and promote infighting. As alluded to above, the political consultants active on the Republican side command huge paychecks, provide little to no work, all while fostering political bickering to keep their business alive. When a candidate hires a consultant, they should ask whether or not the consultant has ever been on a winning race, check their answer out, as well as their references. Do a criminal background check, since many have checkered pasts that can bring down a campaign.

In conclusion, the three points above will not single-handedly turn the party around, but it's a good start.

February 13, 2008 at 10:32 a.m.
6

Dan Kelley says:

Those Lincoln Day dinners must have been wonderful yesterday.

Oh, I forgot, Obama launched his Democratic Party campaign by declaring himself to be the new Lincoln while in Springfield. This was before he claimed to be the new JFK before he claimed that he was going to contest the title of the first black president with Bill Clinton. If he gets a wheelchair or a cigarette holder, maybe he can be FDR.

February 13, 2008 at 10:33 a.m.
7

Yawn says:

How ludicrous when masters of disaster like Charlie Johnston show up at the crash site to offer sympathy and more advice.

Just go away.

February 13, 2008 at 3:30 p.m.
8

Charlie Fan says:

Good analysis, Charlie and Stan. I wonder if Heath objects to one-party rule in DuPage County, where 100% of the county elected officials belong to the same party?

February 13, 2008 at 4:24 p.m.
9

True Republican says:

The Republican party in Illinois is truely in a disaster mode. We have no leaders and no energy.
Our so called leaders a listless,dull and boring.No one inspires the voters,plus there well known "conformists".
Andy McKenna is the worst thing to happen to us.His dull and ridiculous actions(defending Mayor Daley against the Republican Cook County President) was embarassing.
Other GOP'ers such as Birkett,Schillirstrom,Cross,Cronin,Bradley,Oberweis,Radagno,Saviano,Durkin and Peraica are alll useless, embarassing,clowns who make our party voters to embarassed to say they support them!
Unless we expand our party from boring white middle age men with no life experience,unless we expand to bring in more women and stop hating others and playing the race card, the Republicans in Illinois are going to be just like those old 8 track tapes from the past,which is extinct!

February 13, 2008 at 7:42 p.m.
10

I'm a fan of Robbins and Sloan! says:

I think the state Republicans should reach out to local leaders ,such as Don Sloan and Tom Robbins from Westchester . I believe that these two should be named Cook County Republican leaders then our Party will grow and win elections!
Robbins for State Rep. and Sloan for state Senator!

February 13, 2008 at 7:47 p.m.
11

appalled citizen says:

Don't trust the Good Ole Boy network. They're corrupt, and have been for years.
I wish the Green Party would rise, so I wouldn't have to waste my votes.
The 2 party system sucks, and doesn't work.

February 14, 2008 at 1:12 p.m.

Comments are closed for this entry